Haryana Posted December 22, 2023 Share Posted December 22, 2023 Express your opinion on the Poll. Thanks. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Haryana Posted December 24, 2023 Author Share Posted December 24, 2023 @Thrifty3000 What you think? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Thrifty3000 Posted December 26, 2023 Share Posted December 26, 2023 (edited) On 12/24/2023 at 5:41 PM, Haryana said: @Thrifty3000 What you think? I voted no, but mostly because $2,000 would require a slightly more optimistic outlook than I’m comfortable with. I’m assuming BV will be around $1,500 per share by the end of 2027, and I believe 1.2x BV ($1,800) is a reasonably conservative multiple for FFH. Now, with that said, given how unpredictable Mr. Market is, and how well FFH has been managing capital in recent years, I do think there’s maybe a 50/50 chance the share price could at least touch the $2,000 per share mark by the end of 2027. So, I’m not a hard no. I just don’t want to set myself up for disappointment. Edited December 26, 2023 by Thrifty3000 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Haryana Posted December 27, 2023 Author Share Posted December 27, 2023 @Thrifty3000 thank you for expressing what you think. Everyone, please feel free to explain your side of the bet. Projecting 2000 from the current 900 is a rate of 22% or 23% with dividends. You should be on the Yes team if you are estimating that rate over four years. Also, this is like an American style option where you can win anytime before the expiration. The Yes team will win as soon as either the book value or the share price touches US2000. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Ross812 Posted December 28, 2023 Share Posted December 28, 2023 I voted no. From @Viking: For Fairfax, today only 20% of their various income streams comes from underwriting profit and 80% comes from other sources (40% from interest and dividends, 20% from share of profit of associates and 20% from mark to market equities and investment gains). Underwriting profit is a much more important income stream for traditional P/C insurers. So even if the CR at Fairfax declines slightly in the coming years (this is not a given), given its small relative size, it will likely have a small impact on Fairfax’s total earnings - the total $ decline will likely easily be absorbed by another income stream. To get to $2000 I'll make the optimistic assumption that EPS are $200 in 2024-2027 and FFH rerates to 1.2x BV. I assume that interest rates are headed back down a couple of percentage points which means over the next few years the ability to easily reinvest cash (both retained earnings and maturities) back into treasuries/bonds becomes less profitable. The 40% share of profit from interest and dividends comes from the float and I don't see the float increasing at 20%+ percent a year which means FFH has to rely on other sources - underwriting profit, profit from associates, 20% MTM investment gains. Declining interest payments is a big hole to fill and FFH hasn't done it in the past, even if you look at the profitability of the SOTP ex-hedges in the past. Remember there is a high probability (40-50%) underwriting disappoints in one of the next 4 years. Maybe that extends/renews a hard market and FFH ends up better for it over a full cycle, but that could be a significant whack to earnings in any one year. To get to $2000, a lot of things have to go right: a) high interest rates continue -or- they knock investments out of the park (maybe 30% chance) b) no super cats in the next 4 years (50% chance) c) market rerates FFH to 1.2x BV (I'd say 80% chance) So that is a 12% chance FFH ends up at $2000. My estimation: Starting BVPS - $890 2024 - $170 EPS 2025 - $175 EPS 2026 - $180 EPS 2027 - $170 EPS Underwriting: super cat year knocks off $40 one year Rerate to 1.2x BV BVPS - $1545 Price - $1850 That's a CAGR of about 18% which is good enough for me, 15% of my NW is in FFH. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Viking Posted December 28, 2023 Share Posted December 28, 2023 25 minutes ago, Ross812 said: I voted no. From @Viking: For Fairfax, today only 20% of their various income streams comes from underwriting profit and 80% comes from other sources (40% from interest and dividends, 20% from share of profit of associates and 20% from mark to market equities and investment gains). Underwriting profit is a much more important income stream for traditional P/C insurers. So even if the CR at Fairfax declines slightly in the coming years (this is not a given), given its small relative size, it will likely have a small impact on Fairfax’s total earnings - the total $ decline will likely easily be absorbed by another income stream. To get to $2000 I'll make the optimistic assumption that EPS are $200 in 2024-2027 and FFH rerates to 1.2x BV. I assume that interest rates are headed back down a couple of percentage points which means over the next few years the ability to easily reinvest cash (both retained earnings and maturities) back into treasuries/bonds becomes less profitable. The 40% share of profit from interest and dividends comes from the float and I don't see the float increasing at 20%+ percent a year which means FFH has to rely on other sources - underwriting profit, profit from associates, 20% MTM investment gains. Declining interest payments is a big hole to fill and FFH hasn't done it in the past, even if you look at the profitability of the SOTP ex-hedges in the past. Remember there is a high probability (40-50%) underwriting disappoints in one of the next 4 years. Maybe that extends/renews a hard market and FFH ends up better for it over a full cycle, but that could be a significant whack to earnings in any one year. To get to $2000, a lot of things have to go right: a) high interest rates continue -or- they knock investments out of the park (maybe 30% chance) b) no super cats in the next 4 years (50% chance) c) market rerates FFH to 1.2x BV (I'd say 80% chance) So that is a 12% chance FFH ends up at $2000. My estimation: Starting BVPS - $890 2024 - $170 EPS 2025 - $175 EPS 2026 - $180 EPS 2027 - $170 EPS Underwriting: super cat year knocks off $40 one year Rerate to 1.2x BV BVPS - $1545 Price - $1850 That's a CAGR of about 18% which is good enough for me, 15% of my NW is in FFH. @Ross812 from my perspective the big unknown with Fairfax is asset sales/monetizations/revaluations. Will be get one big one - +$500 million - over the next 4 years? Two big ones? Or do we get a number of smaller ones - $250 million to $500 million - like the 2 we saw in 2023 (Ambridge and GIG). - Digit IPO and getting to 74% ownership - Anchorage IPO - BIAL - Stelco - does it get taken out? - AGT Food Ingredients - delivered +$100 million in EBITDA in 2022 (if i remember correctly). Time to spin out? - Foran Mining - will we need more copper in about 2 years? I could go on. Fairfax has lots of levers to pull to surface significant value. Bottom line, one or two big moves here (or a number of smaller moves) would really move the needle in terms of BV growth, which would likely pop the stock price. What i like about Fairfax today is most investors expect zero in their earnings estimates / valuation models for big gains. I don’t build them into my models (until they are announced) - hence why i think my estimates will likely prove to be conservative. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
vinod1 Posted December 28, 2023 Share Posted December 28, 2023 Guys answering yes, please tell me what you are inhaling! This is a large, very large part of my portfolio and dont need you guys angering the market gods!!! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Crip1 Posted December 28, 2023 Share Posted December 28, 2023 55 minutes ago, vinod1 said: Guys answering yes, please tell me what you are inhaling! This is a large, very large part of my portfolio and dont need you guys angering the market gods!!! You sound like my trying to not anger Fantasy Football Gods. Regarding this question, however, I also voted "No" for two non-analytical reasons. First, something or some things are going to surprise us in the coming months/years. it's better the assume "Good" and get "Great" or assume "OK" and get "Good" than the inverse. I literally just finished handing in the revenue budget for my company and, as usual, said "We're expecting X but we're budgeting for .9 times X in terms of volume and margins". It's not right to low-ball, but it's better to assume conservatively. Bad surprises are hard to manage, good surprises are much easier to manage. The second reason goes back to something Buffett said years ago and still rings true. In insurance, surprises are more often bad than they are good. Everything normalized is pointing higher, and FFH is my largest position by far, but if something happens unexpected and material, it's likely not going to be good. -Crip Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
cwericb Posted December 29, 2023 Share Posted December 29, 2023 I voted 'NO', only because I have concerns about future climate change and how that will impact the industry - and I too, am a little afraid to anger the investment gods. Of course 'No' is the safe answer because I hope I am wrong and that the industry and Fairfax will find ways to cope with climate change and potential future disasters that may occur. However, since FFH is now about 55% of my stock portfolio, I am still reluctant to lighten up and am confident that Fairfax will continue to produce satisfactory results. Even if it misses that $2000 mark by a bit I wouldn't be too disappointed I am just a small investor compared to many here, but I first looked at Fairfax back in 2006. I followed it closely on the predecessors to this board (Thanks Sanjeev!) and made my first venture into the markets with a substantial (to me) purchase of Fairfax in 2007 at about $220/share. AND, at the time kicking myself that I didn't buy earlier when it was about half that price. Seems to me one of the posters I followed closely back in the early days was Crip (above and thanks) and a surprisingly high number of others that are still around here today. I have yet to sell a share and have added throughout the years and only stopped because it is uncomfortably overweight in my portfolio. My biggest concern at this point is the Capital Gains Tax should I ever decide to sell. Ouch - but a nice problem to have I guess. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Haryana Posted December 29, 2023 Author Share Posted December 29, 2023 21 hours ago, vinod1 said: Guys answering yes, please tell me what you are inhaling! This is a large, very large part of my portfolio and dont need you guys angering the market gods!!! Wondering if you might be exhibiting some Wall of Worry phase type symptoms. Are you feeling some fears/worries that you are avoiding either side of the bet? (as all can see and for those who are yet to notice, this poll is nonanonymous) Even the No team members are estimating a price point of 1800/1850. The movements based on history are expected to be volatile/lumpy. Touching 2000 intraday is only a ~10% volatility from 1800/1850. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
vinod1 Posted December 29, 2023 Share Posted December 29, 2023 50 minutes ago, Haryana said: Wondering if you might be exhibiting some Wall of Worry phase type symptoms. Are you feeling some fears/worries that you are avoiding either side of the bet? (as all can see and for those who are yet to notice, this poll is nonanonymous) Even the No team members are estimating a price point of 1800/1850. The movements based on history are expected to be volatile/lumpy. Touching 2000 intraday is only a ~10% volatility from 1800/1850. I am completely kidding of course. I go a long way back with Fairfax. First purchase at $106 in 2006. Very small purchase as I did not know much. Second stock I bought after Berkshire. Added and reduced several times all the way until 2011 when I exited the investment completely at $418 when it is pretty obvious that returns are going to be poor. Got back in at scale at various price points between $450 to $485 in the last couple of years. To me it meets the minimum return requirements with a high degree of certainty with possibility of higher returns. I intent to hold it for a long time as conditions have changed and it has become just as obvious now that returns are going to be very satisfactory as it was in 2011 that returns would be unsatisfactory. No need to nail down a specific price. I am not selling even if it reaches some arbitrary price point as long as my return expectations meet my minimum requirements and/or other opportunities show up. The moment we make an investment part of our rationality goes out. When we comment on it, more rationality goes out. When we start putting price estimates with dates, we all tend to start exhibiting various forms of bias. That is the only reason I did not vote and do not comment too much on this topic. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Haryana Posted December 30, 2023 Author Share Posted December 30, 2023 @vinod1 thank you for sharing your experience and insights. This poll is also like a game to practice emotional detachment. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Hamburg Investor Posted December 31, 2023 Share Posted December 31, 2023 I voted yes, assuming I had to bet 1 dollar and getting an extra dollar being right or loosing the dollar being wrong (3rd option: not betting at all = dollar gone). Base case would be a cagr a little bit above 15 per cent, so bv/share around 1500 dollar (dividends subtracted). Could be 20 per cent (around 1700 dollar). Would a pb ratio of 1.33 be thinkable for Fairfax Financial with a cagr of 15% in the rearview mirror over a timeframe of 7 years than (not knowing the outlook than, which will be more important, but still) as an intraday touch at the end of 2027? Maybe. What about Mr. Market felling in love at one point in the upcoming 4 years with the insurance sector once again? It seems a long time ago, but before 2007 (that is before interest rates dropped) pb ratios above 1.5 where nothing special for a lot of insurance stocks (e. g. here’s a graph with BRK, MKL and Fairfax: https://tidefall.substack.com/p/2022-fairfax-letter-highlights). I am not predicting that, but within the framing of this bet it gives some extra per cent for a yes. Maybe this happens in 2025, in 2030 or 2070 - who knows. Still it gives a little bit of an extra opportunity. If the cagr of book is above 15 per cent (odds are good in my view) than an intraday pb ratio of 1.2 or so seems more likely. Adding up all those a “touch” for me seems to have better opportunities than a “no touch”. Would I bet on a price tag of 2000 dollar or above on December 31st 2027? Probably not. Am I predicting a touch of 2000 dollar until end of 2027? No. I just answered the question and to me a touch just feels more likely than a “no touch”. IMHO the odds are above 50 per cent. P.S: Buybacks should give an extra push to the bvps. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Haryana Posted December 31, 2023 Author Share Posted December 31, 2023 @Hamburg Investor thank you for your opinion and participation. The poll closes in a few hours, enter now to play in this tug of war. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
SafetyinNumbers Posted January 1 Share Posted January 1 14 minutes ago, Haryana said: @Hamburg Investor thank you for your opinion and participation. The poll closes in a few hours, enter now to play in this tug of war. Thanks for putting up the poll. Interesting results! I wonder where the group would place the odds of touching US$2000 by the end of 2027 and how that would relate to the result of the poll. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Haryana Posted January 3 Author Share Posted January 3 Thanks to all the participants for equally dividing themselves on each team unless it was some magical golden triangulation of coincidence. The stage is set for an epic showdown between the Yes team and the No team with multiple heavyweights (just brain weight) on each side. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
cwericb Posted January 3 Share Posted January 3 Yes, but only the 'No" team hopes the other side wins. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Haryana Posted January 4 Author Share Posted January 4 On 1/3/2024 at 5:40 AM, cwericb said: Yes, but only the 'No" team hopes the other side wins. Are you wanting to switch from the No team to the Yes side Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Haryana Posted January 24 Author Share Posted January 24 FRFHF touches US $ 1000 Last updated: Jan 24, 2024, 11:35 AM ET Source: QuoteMedia Open 993.81 Day High/Low 1,000.00/987.00 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
KFS Posted January 24 Share Posted January 24 3 hours ago, Haryana said: FRFHF touches US $ 1000 Last updated: Jan 24, 2024, 11:35 AM ET Source: QuoteMedia Open 993.81 Day High/Low 1,000.00/987.00 Half way there! .... Take my hand and we'll make it I swear! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Buffett_Groupie Posted January 24 Share Posted January 24 5 hours ago, Haryana said: FRFHF touches US $ 1000 Last updated: Jan 24, 2024, 11:35 AM ET Source: QuoteMedia Open 993.81 Day High/Low 1,000.00/987.00 Enjoy Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Haryana Posted January 24 Author Share Posted January 24 (edited) 8 hours ago, KFS said: Half way there! .... Take my hand and we'll make it I swear! You got that right, just gotta HODL with in this tug of war! "We've got to hold on, ready or not" Edited January 25 by Haryana Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Haryana Posted January 25 Author Share Posted January 25 (edited) On 1/24/2024 at 9:43 AM, Haryana said: FRFHF touches US $ 1000 Last updated: Jan 24, 2024, 11:35 AM ET Source: QuoteMedia Open 993.81 Day High/Low 1,000.00/987.00 (HODL Anthem) " We've got to hold on to what we got it doesn't make a difference if we make it or not We got each other and that's a lot for love - We'll give it a shot We're half way there Livin' on a prayer Take my hand and we'll make it, I swear Livin' on a prayer We've got to hold on, ready or not You live for the fight when it's all that you've got We're half way there Livin' on a prayer " Edited January 31 by Haryana HODL Anthem Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Haryana Posted April 6 Author Share Posted April 6 May I dedicate this song to the up and down volatility of the Fairfax stock - ♪ Can you feel it, baby ♪ ♪ I can too ♪ ♪ Come on swing it ♪ ♪ Now we come to the pay off ♪ ♪ It's such a good vibration ♪ ♪ It's such a sweet sensation ♪ ♪ And I'm here to prove to you ♪ ♪ That we can party on the positive side ♪ ♪ And pump positive vibes ♪ ♪ So come along for the ride ♪ ♪ If you ain't in it to win it ♪ ♪ Then get the hell out ♪ ♪ It's such a good vibration ♪ ♪ It's such a sweet sensation ♪ Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Haryana Posted April 12 Author Share Posted April 12 BRK vs FFH over 20 years: Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now