DooDiligence Posted November 19, 2024 Posted November 19, 2024 32 minutes ago, pricingpower said: I was just thinking the other day how it's odd that forest fire liability risk has been likely massively growing for rails over the last decade but never gets talked about outside of a utilities context. One structural advantage trucking is going to grow is that no one will be able to extract a $50bn settlement for starting a forest fire while deep pocketed rails are probably increasingly exposed... One time payouts vs being pecked to death.
dealraker Posted November 25, 2024 Author Posted November 25, 2024 So today I thought I'd just mention that my railroad stocks are again roaring to the upside given the super-duper economy - as of course the economy was absolutely terrible a month ago. But anyway I own all the rails, all the US for somewhere between 30-some and almost 50 years (NSC). I thought I'd share something, given the OR obsessions and whatnot. Now I'm going on memory here so bear with me (cause I'm old and have no memory): UNP sales growth for the last ten years in total? Wanna bet? My bet is about zero. Am I right? NSC sales growth for the last ten years total? Hmm...I'll wager mid single digits. CSX sales growth for the last ten years total? Hmm...last I saw it was maybe very low double digits. Just making sure everyone's got somewhat of an off-Wall Street view from an owner. Unlike 99% of investors old dealraker doesn't mind at all discussing the reality of his stuff while most endlessly chant euphoria till the day their stuff is sold- then it is bombs away. I know, I know...they laid off unprofitable sales or whatever. Profits per share are up of course in the last 10 by a pretty good bit. Oh...and debt growth for the last ten? Seems there were some buybacks using debt along the way. I guess "sales-to-debt" isn't a normal financial metric sold to shareholders. Hoping for the best of course.
rogermunibond Posted December 2, 2024 Posted December 2, 2024 CP still trading at a premium to NA rail but for how long? Use the sell off as a buying point. https://www.wsj.com/business/logistics/the-railroad-on-the-wrong-side-of-trumps-tariffs-51d1a1bc?mod=hp_lead_pos10
dealraker Posted December 5, 2024 Author Posted December 5, 2024 coffeecaninvestor mentioned the railroads on another topic and alluded to a post I had just made recently as to RR sales of the last ten years. I'm actually a tad more upbeat on the railroads than that post may have presented. So basically the rails have been left out of the most recent years run-up of the markets, and they should have been left out. Norfolk had the disaster thing going and the stock of course temporarily tanked, but for the most part all of the RR's have just been spinning in neutral for a while. I'd think that will change, if and when there's more stuff on track to be shipped. All of the RR's are equipped to run hot should it - the stuff that needs to be RR shipped - come. So in that respect I do think the industry is in good condition and ready. Valuations are appropriate, not high or low in my limited opinion. So over time I think the RR's to be a decent place to invest.
coffeecaninvestor Posted December 5, 2024 Posted December 5, 2024 Thoughts on the Canadian rails? I was pretty focused on CNI since I owned it. They seem to be in a tougher situation with the new administration and trading at a premium to US rails. If on shoring continues I could a see a more favorable return from US rails.
dealraker Posted December 6, 2024 Author Posted December 6, 2024 On 12/5/2024 at 10:23 AM, coffeecaninvestor said: Thoughts on the Canadian rails? I was pretty focused on CNI since I owned it. They seem to be in a tougher situation with the new administration and trading at a premium to US rails. If on shoring continues I could a see a more favorable return from US rails. It is going to be interesting to see what the Canadian rails deal with as to the DJT administration. While I own them all and don't consider the stock prices crazy high I'm still not aware of what's coming along to give them more volume and sales growth outside of inflation pricing. I bought NSC averaging in around a bit below $200 during the East Palestine tragedy but as of yet I've seen no other stock prices I'd be tempted with given what seems - at least to me - to be little coming along to up their game. NSC will get their OR down some from where it is now but that's already in the stock price it seems to me. That said, I'm an long term owner but I'm not an expert of the cycles and trends that make would help make a good timed buy.
Dinar Posted December 6, 2024 Posted December 6, 2024 24 minutes ago, dealraker said: It is going to be interesting to see what the Canadian rails deal with as to the DJT administration. While I own them all and don't consider the stock prices crazy high I'm still not aware of what's coming along to give them more volume and sales growth outside of inflation pricing. I bought NSC averaging in around a bit below $200 during the East Palestine tragedy but as of yet I've seen no other stock prices I'd be tempted with given what seems - at least to me - to be little coming along to up their game. NSC will get their OR down some from where it is now but that's already in the stock price it seems to me. That said, I'm an long term owner but I'm not an expert of the cycles and trends that make would help make a good timed buy. Charlie, CP claimed in its 2023 investor day that they would be able to squeeze out USD 5bn in revenue synergies from the merger thanks to higher volumes. I would guess that these volumes would come at 70% EBIT margin, vs 40-45% for the pre-merger business. There were also obviously cost synergies which they tried to downplay (CEO, CFO, CTO, COO, board of directors, treasurer, and hundreds of other corporate staff. I think the KCS board + executives consumed $20MM per annum.) They are finishing the 2nd bridge at Laredo which should cut 6 hours from the train journey from/to Mexico one way, so 12 hours round trip - massive savings. I am getting to a 9%+ free cash flow yield to the equity in 2028, assuming maintenance cap ex is CAD 900MM higher per annum than D&A.
Spekulatius Posted December 7, 2024 Posted December 7, 2024 On CP- 20% incremental revenue growth and 70% incremental EBITDA margins seem high. Right now they are scratching 40% EBITDA margins and it takes a one hell of a business to go higher than that. CP is a quintessential play on NAFTA:
Dinar Posted December 7, 2024 Posted December 7, 2024 3 hours ago, Spekulatius said: On CP- 20% incremental revenue growth and 70% incremental EBITDA margins seem high. Right now they are scratching 40% EBITDA margins and it takes a one hell of a business to go higher than that. CP is a quintessential play on NAFTA: a) It is not a 40% EBITDA margin, it is a 40% EBIT margin (albeit overstated since D&A is less than maintenance cap ex) b) Historically CP was in the mid 40s EBIT margin and KCS was in the 80s. It was widely acknowledged that material operating improvements could be made at KCS. c) Incremental volumes are extraordinarily profitable. Look historically at any railroad, how say a 5% volume increase impacted profits. d) Yes, it is a NAFTA play.
dealraker Posted December 11, 2024 Author Posted December 11, 2024 (edited) Most railroad discussions are stuck in the past, they discuss operating ratios and HH. Here we go, slowly getting up from the Rip Van Winkle to what has been the New New Thing for a while. Very simple and obvious place to start right here. And unrelated to this article....yes the CP thing does seem to make sense to me. https://www.trains.com/trn/news-reviews/news-wire/carload-considerations-will-pricing-above-inflation-work-indefinitely/ Edited December 24, 2024 by dealraker grammar/spelling
Spekulatius Posted December 12, 2024 Posted December 12, 2024 I wonder about the math to 9% FCF with CP in 2028, way above consensus. Raising prices above inflation won’t work forever either. I think self driving trucks will be a thing and quite deflationary on Transportation costs and that will affect RR’s too. FCF yield for most RR’s seems to be below 4% which seems rich.
Dinar Posted December 24, 2024 Posted December 24, 2024 On 12/12/2024 at 4:56 PM, Spekulatius said: I wonder about the math to 9% FCF with CP in 2028, way above consensus. Raising prices above inflation won’t work forever either. I think self driving trucks will be a thing and quite deflationary on Transportation costs and that will affect RR’s too. FCF yield for most RR’s seems to be below 4% which seems rich. Here is the math on 9% 2028 FCF yield: a) 2023 pro-forma revenue = CAD 13.9bn, and 38% adjusted EBIT margin. b) At 3% inflation = 2028 EBIT CAD 6.123bn, assuming 38% adjusted EBIT margin. Assuming pricing is 0.5% above inflation every year increases 2028 EBIT by CAD 395MM. b) I am assuming 7% annual volume growth for the 5 year period (which is at the high end of company guidance from 2023 investor day, and the company historically under-promised and over-delivered). This should result in a 40.26% volume growth. I am assuming 70% EBIT incremental margins, which should increase EBIT by CAD 4.652bn c) Cap ex to exceed depreciation by CAD 700MM per annum (Cap ex = CAD 2.7bn per annum and d&a around CAD 2bn) d) Cumulative free cash flow = CAD 15.3bn CAD over a 3 year period 2025-2028, which will be used to buy-back 144 of shares o/s at CAD 100 each e) 2028 free cash flow: CAD 11.17bn EBIT - CAD 800MM interest - CAD 700MM (Cap ex - D&A) - CAD 2418MM (tax) = CAD 7.25bn CAD or divided by 795MM shares = CAD 9.14 per share vs CAD 105.33 = 8.7%. Time will tell on self-driving trucks. I think that before you get self-driving trucks, you will get self-driving trains. I think there will be pressure from environmental groups to switch freight to rail, and also highway congestion is getting worse. I would not be surprised if there is a tax on trucks that gets implemented to make them pay for highway damage.
Dinar Posted December 24, 2024 Posted December 24, 2024 For those worried about tariffs on Mexico, interesting interview with Jared Kushner. He seems to be very bullish on Mexico manufacturing and exporting to the US. So he clearly is not expecting his father in law to kill trade with Mexico.
Spekulatius Posted December 25, 2024 Posted December 25, 2024 On 12/23/2024 at 10:13 PM, Dinar said: For those worried about tariffs on Mexico, interesting interview with Jared Kushner. He seems to be very bullish on Mexico manufacturing and exporting to the US. So he clearly is not expecting his father in law to kill trade with Mexico. Mexican stocks seem to disagree so maybe there is an opportunity here if the view above is correct. FWIW, there is a Mexican RR stock GMXT that could be an interesting play here as well. @Dinar thanks for the math on CP. I think the volume growth assumptions and conversion of revenue into EBIT are higher than consensus. The consensus for FCF in 2028 is also way lower as far as I can tell. If CP can make your scenario happen, it’s certainly a buy here.
Dinar Posted December 25, 2024 Posted December 25, 2024 47 minutes ago, Spekulatius said: Mexican stocks seem to disagree so maybe there is an opportunity here if the view above is correct. FWIW, there is a Mexican RR stock GMXT that could be an interesting play here as well. @Dinar thanks for the math on CP. I think the volume growth assumptions and conversion of revenue into EBIT are higher than consensus. The consensus for FCF in 2028 is also way lower as far as I can tell. If CP can make your scenario happen, it’s certainly a buy here. Yes, I know GMXT but I cannot find English financials and I also don't know the controlling shareholders.
Spekulatius Posted December 25, 2024 Posted December 25, 2024 12 minutes ago, Dinar said: Yes, I know GMXT but I cannot find English financials and I also don't know the controlling shareholders. Grupo Mexico are the controlling shareholders. They have a reputation as good operators but also ruthless. I do not know where the ruthless part comes from, so this may be discounted.
KPO Posted December 25, 2024 Posted December 25, 2024 4 minutes ago, Spekulatius said: Grupo Mexico are the controlling shareholders. They have a reputation as good operators but also ruthless. I do not know where the ruthless part comes from, so this may be discounted. I’ve bought and sold GMBXF a few times over the years as the railroad is typically ascribed negative value after backing out the ~90% SCCO stake. Interesting to see you bring this up as I’ve been looking at it again since the election. The US needs Mexico (and Canada) if we want to continue to decouple from the Asian region.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now