Leaderboard

The situation in Canada is frightening. The more i think about it, the more our situation is beginning to parallel the US in 2006 or 2007. The key is ‘higher for longer.’ If rates stay around current levels for the next year i think we will see the beginning of big problems in the housing market in Canada. The cracks are there already. Higher for longer, if it happens, means our mortgage market today is just like the wacky mortgage market the US had in 2005-2007. People don’t see it… the real estate market here is definitely giving off ‘Big Short’ vibes right now. Maybe i need to go to a local strip club and do some proper research. I was listening to a local real estate podcast (the Tom Storey show) and the guest realtor they had on said repeatedly “we all know real estate prices only go up.” She sounded like a nice lady… reminded me of ‘its just a gully.’ The issue was crazy low teaser rates… these allowed people to buy a house to live in they could not afford. But why let a good thing go to waste? Many Canadians became real estate ‘investors’ and started buying multiple real estate properties as well. The big difference in the US and Canada is the crazy low low teaser rates in Canada have been available for a decade. This has allowed fortunes to be made on real estate in a very short period of time. I have been one of the winners (although i now rent - i cashed out my winning ticket in 2021). Canada’s entire economy became focussed on one asset class: real estate (as a % of GDP). And Canadians are obsessed with real estate. Low teaser rates for a decade have blown a real estate bubble of epic proportions. In Canada when people buy a house it is usually done with a mortgage that has a variable interest rate (changes immediately when rates change) or a 5 year fixed interest rate. I think amortizations can be a max of 30 years. For 40 years, a variable rate mortgage was a winning horse - for these borrowers interest costs kept falling every year. During covid variable rate mortgages dropped below 1%. More risk averse Canadians take out a 5 year fixed rate mortgage. These also fell over 40 years and bottomed at 1.39% during covid. As interest rates fell for 40 years straight, well house prices have done the opposite and gone straight up for close to 20 years. Guess how much house you can ‘afford’ if you pay under 1.5% on your mortgage? House prices in Canada experienced their blow off top in Feb and March of 2022. The increase has been epic. Today a 5 year fixed rate mortgage is about 6.2%. Variable rate mortgages are higher than this. ‘Higher for longer’ means any Canadians who have an oversized mortgage (there are more than a few) are screwed. So where is the carnage? Everything looks ok? Most of the variable rate mortgages have a uniquely Canadian twist… they are called ‘adjustable’. If interest rates go higher the borrower can pay more in interest and less in principal - but the total mortgage payment does not change. To make the math work, the amortization period is extended. Lots of variable rate mortgages in Canada now have 40 or more year amortizations (yes, when 30 is the max) and some are as high as 70/years. Some of these mortgages are so far offside that the total mortgage payment is no longer covering all the interest costs - the mortgage balance is actually increasing for these loans. Here is where the story gets interesting. All mortgages in Canada will reset every 5 years (variable and fixed rate). That means about every year 20% of all mortgages will be up for renewal. This is when everything gets ‘trued up’ - total payment and amortization. Of course, 6.2% is NOT generally workable if you have a large mortgage. So ‘higher for longer’, if it lasts, is a death sentence for Canada’s housing bubble. But it will take another year or so to become more apparent. Investors are starting to cry uncle. Since about 2015 most real estate purchases in Canada for ‘investing’ were already cash flow negative - even at the low ‘teaser’ mortgage rates. House prices were going up 6-8% per year. Being mildly cash flow negative was simply a cost of doing business. At 6.2% today investors are getting taken out behind the woodshed - their monthly costs and losses have mushroomed in the thousands of dollars. The icing on the cake is, in Vancouver and some parts of Toronto, landlords can’t raise their rent much (Vancouver allowed a rent increase of 1.5% in 2022 and a 2% rent increase in 2023). And the price appreciation has stopped. So investors are screwed. But they are a hardy lot. And, after all, interest rates WILL come back down. Canadian housing ONLY goes up. What is a rational investor to do? Buy and hold. Hang in there. Well, losing thousands of dollars every month eventually works it magic. Like a splash of cold water on the face, ‘investors’ are starting to - well - run out of cash to burn. Not surprisingly, we are seeing higher rates hit the investor part of the market first. For sale inventory is starting to build - and about 50% of it appears to be from investors. Where this gets interesting is where we go from here. If inventory continues to build and we start to see prices fall 10%. If you are an investor and you are deeply cash flow negative AND real estate prices start to correct lower… you are worse than screwed. Now you risk getting wiped out financially. Leverage is a bitch when it goes against you. Within the investor segment, the condo pre-sale market could get very ugly in the coming year. Lots of ‘investors’ put down a deposit years ago on a unit that they intended to flip at a much higher price once it was completed. This strategy was a license to print money for years. These ‘investors’ can’t now sell the unit when it comes to market as the selling price is going to be below their agreed to purchase price so they will lose their deposit (or more). And they can’t buy the unit either - they do not quality for a mortgage at 6.2%. Lots of people own multiple units like this. A legal shitstorm in the making. For borrowers who live in their residence this whole thing gets complicated. Canadians are very resilient at finding solutions - so i am not sure how it plays out here. Other than mortgage payments are going through the roof for those carrying large mortgages. But it will take a few more years to fully play out. The big banks will work with mortgage holders. They will extend amortizations to take the sting away a little. The Liberal government will also likely try and do something. So perhaps we muddle through. ‘Higher for longer’ will be the key of how this plays out. But the storm clouds are forming. And it looks like it might actually pick up enough speed to become a hurricane…

Our tax dollars aren't going to Wagner, they're going to our politicians and to Ukraine. Why shouldn't it be a problem if these folks end up supporting extremists? The longer this war drags on the more Ukrainians & Russians will die. Why aren't we trying to get Ukraine to negotiate for peace? France brokered a ceasefire between Georgia and Russia after 7 days, saving countless lives, why can't that happen here? Does the West really care about Ukrainians or are we using them to give the finger to Russia? If we cared so much about Ukrainian lives, why don't we send our own troops instead?

https://foreignpolicy.com/2023/09/22/ukraine-war-ethics-morality-murky/