steph

I would vote ‘Yes’ even though I realise it would be an amazing outcome. I totally agree with what is written here about book value around 1500 by the end of 2027. What surprises me is this ‘anchoring’ about valuation. I have been in this business now for over 30 years and the biggest or one of the biggest opportunities is when a certain valuation starts to seem like totally normal, but people forget that there have been periods with very different valuations. My believe is that if and that’s a big ‘if’, FFH continues executing as they have been doing lately AND investing in quality assets, they will get a rerating. For a company doing between 10 and 15% CAGR with quality assets and quality management I would think that the market could easily pay 1,5 times book. Even though insurance companies are historically not expensive today, you can find many with way higher P/B ratios. There will most certainly be a time when FFH will be priced at 1,5 to 2 times book and only then will people start to find that a very reasonable valuation. By then, 1 or 1,2 times book will be seen as extremely cheap and the opportunity of a lifetime.

India is a nice diversification and I believe they have good connections there, which is important. However, I prefer that the bulk of investments is in ‘hard currency’ countries such as the US, Canada and Europe. The Indian Rupee has halved over the last 15 years. It is often the case that growth is interesting but in the end the currency eats a lot of the performance. I hope they will invest most of their capital like Buffett does: in legislations that are kind to investors and stable and in solid currencies. Mostly just close to home.

The longer it lasts the more ridiculous he becomes.

....and 15 times earnings. FFh could double and still be cheaper than WRB.

What if you manage a fund?

I used to agree with this, but much less nowadays. Reason being that with BRK you also pay 1,4 times the value of Apple and other huge listed portfolio + huge cash pile. You don’t pay the real value of the unlisted companies, but you pay a big premium on cash and listed portfolio that has become a very big part of BRK.

Thx Haryana!

Somebody on the board knows if there are any other interesting meetings/presentations the day(s) before the annual meeting? Thx

@Vikingthe only thing that will certainly happen in the coming years, but we don't know when, is a high catastrophe year with very bad combined ratios. Business as usual, but it will impact your 25% compound.

Not so sure that FFH book value is more inflated than competitors. At Markel the difference between book and tangible book is also quite big. And with Berkshire you have a lot of hidden value, many companies that are worth much more than what book says, but on the other hand you have today, more than ever, 200 billion in Apple, 150 billion in cash plus all other equity holdings for which you pay 1.35 times book.

You don't only pay a higher P/B multiple because of high expeced return on book. You pay a higher multiple because of the notion of quality. Quality company, quality management,... . Fairfax got a low P/B because of distrust towards management and the idea that FFH was lower quality. With what they have just done I sincerely do believe that the market will reward them again with a P/B more in line with quality competitors. 1.3 to 1.5 times would be reasonable. So if after 2026 rates are lower and ROE will be somewhat lower I am convinced the P/B could be higher as long as they continue doing sensible things.

Very interesting discussion. Thx! Whatever the outcome in 5 or 10 years, Fairfax is today a quite unique risk/return investment. Investing is about probabilities. With Fairfax today you have a bond portfolio consisting of mostly AAA paper and some other quite secure income that will give you 10% for at least the next 3 to 4 years and probably longer. You can buy this at book and all the rest is optionality : good combined ratios/Eurobank/Digit/buying back minorities/ even higher interest rates/ good reinvestments of all this cash coming in/ rerating to a higher price to book….and many more possible surprises. In my eyes, for the next 5 years a certain 10%, a high probability 15% and why not even a good chance of even higher returns (if the market falls in love again with Prem ).

I have been a shareholder for 18 years and have made it a very large position two years ago because the risk/return compared to other opportunities was just unique. A bit like Berkshire at one point around book value when the overall market was expensive. I have always been amazed by Brian Bradstreet and I am surprised he is not better known. He is a true legend. I suppose Bill Gross had a good track record in bond investing, but nobody comes even close to Brian’s track record. And in the end, fixed income is the most important part of the portfolio of any insurance company. Even though the stock is up nicely, I still believe Fairfax is one of the best risk/rewards today. Never have they been in the luxury position of having close to 10% of market cap coming in annually, for at least the next three years, from interest on AAA treasuries. Imagine what they will be able to do with that…. My reasoning is the following: Book at +/- 900 at the end of this year. You add 100 every year, for the next three years. End of 2026 book is at 1200. By then people will finally realize that FFH is worth at least the same multiple as most other insurance companies. Let’s take 1,25 times book (still reasonable). Target stock at 1500 in three years. Return of more or less 20% annually. In the meantime we will probably have to go through bad news regarding Blackberry (which will make a lot of noise). There will certainly be one bad insurance year. But I am convinced that there will also be some very nice surprises that will more than make up. So adding 100 a year to book value is very reasonable in my opinion and 20% a year a high probability outcome.

My reasoning is quite simple. Market Cap is 21 billion. Total portfolio is 55 billion (equity and float). If float is for free (combined ratio = 100) and they average 6% on the portfolio for the coming years…that is 3,3 billion before interest expense on debt and corporate costs. But let’s assume we roughly arrive at 12-14% return on actual market cap. If you then assume a combined of 98 for the coming years instead of 100, you can add a 2-3% return a year. So from here (with the higher interest rates) I expect they will ‘easily’ achieve the 15% return on book. Therefore at book I estimate it is much too cheap. 1,3 to 1,5 times book would be a very decent price. Margin of safety when buying today is very interesting.