Or maybe it is? He runs funds, has AUM, earns a living with terrible performance. In some ways he proves the point, if you can tell a good story and pull on those value heart strings performance doesn't matter.
The long term numbers for his Canadian flagship fund remain very good. He also helped make FFH a pot-load of money on the CDS position in 2008. That and he has been extraordinarily good to the FFH community. He is well liked for very good reasons.