Investors are in this because they are expecting 15%+ returns. Prem himself mentioned I think they would not be investing in India if they did not think they can make 20% (OK, that is Prem being Prem ).
Paying 1.5% + 20% performance over 5%, would seem perfectly reasonable for most of these investors when returns are north of 15%.
Realized returns are 8.5%. Worse, these are investors who went to emerging markets seeking higher returns and they find S&P 500 had much higher returns.
Now, they feel stupid for paying the performance fee. So they are going to capitalize the costs and discount it. Hence, the discount to BV.
I dont think the discount would close unless
1) Fairfax India starts generating 15% annual returns, or
2) Fairfax India vastly outperforms US stocks, even if absolute performance does not reach 15%. Investors would be flocking to these non-US alternatives in that case.
Vinod