I'm excited to see Taubes, DeVany, paleo, etc. discussed on this board, but not at all surprised. I think that it is somewhat of a thinking man's diet. I've wondered if anyone else here was into the idea, but since I'm new, didn't want to post and immediately earn a spot at the weird kids' table. I read Mark Sisson's blog, www.marksdailyapple.com. He follows the basic principles of the other guys mentioned. His recommendation is a somewhat modified paleo diet.
I began following this last February with great results. When I started, I did it as an experiment and didn't completely research it. While this is definitely against my nature, it's been nice dropping about 20lbs that I didn't even realize I had to spare. (I don't think I have lost much muscle at all btw.) I've been trying to learn more and more as I go, but don't quiz me yet!