There are always ways to game the system and it would be obvious if he did so. I do think after reviewing the plan that the $1 million salary
should be a bucket that once filled he gets the overflow. I think the hurdle rate is low, but he did give up his hedge fund that probably had some value as its been run for 10 years ( with 13.6% avg return as per Tim Erikson's post though I thought it was higher ). The effective hurdle is probably higher, though i'm not aware of the size of the hedge fund.
The guy has to buy BH stock with the cash recieved anyway so its equivalent to gifting stock to him. He will undoubtedly own a significant percentage of the outstanding shares over time if this passes, but will have a huge carrot in front of him to increase shareholder value.
Its a rich agreement, but as are most CEO's nowadays. I don't own any and don't think its optimal, but its way better than most.
I just think this idea of comparing him to Buffet's current salary etc. is silly.
I think anyone investing in BH is investing in a public hedge fund and basing their investment on Steak n Shake but more on his ability to allocate
money.